re: ipod alternatives??? by rss

September 21, 2006 12:32 AM

voting has closed for this question

dear internet,

I am broke. but I also need music to keep me going! the new 4gb ipod nanos (in color!) are supercute, but I can't afford one... should I :

results 48 votes

buy one anyway ($199) (10 votes)
 21%

buy a refurbished ipod mini 4gb/nano 2gb for $99 (13 votes)
 27%

buy a cheaper, non apple brand - please leave suggestions!!! (7 votes)
 15%

suck it up and enjoy the silence (18 votes)
 38%

metavote: the internet liked this question, did you? the internet is divided on this question, how about you? how was this question? loved it hated it
sign in to tag this question yourself.

comments

  • elapheg says:

    Sony. Creative. Both good.

    Sep 21, 2006 02:05 AM
  • Lynn says:

    IA really cheap alternative is a cd player that can play mp3 cds...I bought one for 22.50 (sony) from ebay to listen to books on cd, but as a bonus, the package included software that allows you to record up to 490 songs on a disk...that is pretty much more music than I personally own. So, for less than 30 bucks (inc. shipping) I got the cd player, software, and a cassette coverter to play it in the car. Pretty cool. Of course, you would need a pc with a cd burner...The model that I bought was D-NE326CK MP3/ATRAC3 CD Walkman, but there are probably others, also. I don't know if this will do what you want it to, but thought I would mention it just in case.

    Sep 21, 2006 07:11 AM
  • squiddie says:

    You could check something like Craigslist to find someone who's upgrading and getting rid of their older iPod. Riskier, but potentially cheaper

    Sep 21, 2006 09:23 AM
  • rss says:

    I thought about getting an mp3 cd player, but I think I need something smaller so can slip it in my pocket when I'm on the subway. I used to have an ipod, but it was stolen out of my backpack (because I couldn't fit it in my pocket!).

    Are the sony/creative brands compatible with mac laptops? The cheaper ones don't seem to have much capactiy, or ability to pick songs...

    Sep 21, 2006 11:06 AM
  • Victorix says:

    I love my creative player - sometimes being more selective because the capacity is lower can be a good thing - a sort of refining process

    Sep 21, 2006 12:36 PM
  • rss says:

    I HAD one, but it got stolen last spring. since then I have been humming in my head a lot, but it's getting old. Also, I will soon be having 40 min subway commutes, and it would be nice to listen to music instead of grumbling.

    Sep 21, 2006 06:19 PM
  • Lynn says:

    I like those sony's that are shaped like beans. They have them on overstock.com. Too cute...someone else can perhaps comment on their functionality.

    Sep 22, 2006 09:55 PM
  • rebectron says:

    I love my nano. Very, very much

    Sep 24, 2006 03:29 AM
  • rss says:

    UPDATE! Thanks for the votes! I just ordered a refurbished nano for $99.

    (also, I went to the apple store to look at the color nanos, and I wasn't super excited about them anymore.)

    Sep 25, 2006 02:09 PM
  • sign in to add a comment.